Published on January 21st, 2013 | by EJC0
5 Steps to Verifying User-Generated Content
When young Arabs took to the streets of North Africa in 2011 to fight for democracy armed with internet-connected mobile phones, few if any were there to shake the foundations of traditional news reporting.
This footage poses challenges for news networks and professional journalists. How can one be sure that the video really shows what it purports to depict?
Having watched the Arab Spring unfold, Carvin is well placed to know the reputable voices on social media – especially those in and around Syria.
“I follow several dozen Syria-related YouTube channels, from individual citizen journalists to large-scale distribution networks like Ugarit News and SNN,” he says. “Unfortunately the video uploads faster than I can keep up with, so I try to focus on video from certain places that are currently hotspots, like Aleppo or Homs.”
On Twitter, Carvin follows “a sizeable list” of people covering news related to Syria, some of who he says “developed pretty good reputations for quality content.” Carvin says his Twitter lists of people covering news in Syria is full of individuals who have developed good reputations for quality content. When news comes across from a source other than those already on his list, Carvin always works to verify it. “I’ll sometimes ask my Twitter followers, or check in with Syrian contacts directly,” Carvin says.
“I try to stick to videos that have some context to them – accents that can be picked out, landmarks in the background, weather, et cetra. I often shy away from videos that have little or no context to them.”Carvin says he believes news networks are becoming better at recognising the benefits and pitfalls of social media.
“I think people have become a lot more thoughtful about scrutinising videos, and the pendulum has swung a few times. Originally, it seemed no news organisations wanted to touch UGC. Then the Arab Spring comes around and they start airing it left and right. Now I think we’re somewhere in the middle – using UGC more selectively.”
Nevertheless, there are limits to how much a video can tell about a situation. As journalism defines its role and processes in relation to user-generated content and “we develop stronger networks of who we trust more than others, hopefully we’re getting better at verification,” Carvin added.
The downfalls to relying solely on social journalism for news are apparent. Carvin says he believes that it can only really work in tandem with professional news reporting, stressing that “there’s still a huge need for people being able to report stories like Syria in person.”
“That in-person connection can turn a good story into a great story,” he said. “So I generally think social journalism and offline journalism complement each other, but can’t necessarily replace the other.”
Newsrooms and social media: Verifying Videos
When it comes to establishing the trustworthiness of activist videos – like those from Syria – there is no one-size-fits-all approach. But here are five things to look out for.
1: The first thing to do when verifying any video is to find the original source, hopefully the person who shot it. Scrutinising the YouTube channel it was published on can provide clues as to if the clip is a scrape or the original. If other videos in the YouTube account were shot in other parts of the country, then it’s likely the uploader is an aggregator and copied the video from elsewhere. It may also be an uploader who is ‘repackaging’ old videos, claiming that they show recent events. By searching YouTube with keywords describing the video, usually in Arabic, it’s often possible to trace the earliest version. Online tools such as Tineye and Google Image Search also help check if a video is old or new.
2: Look for landmarks and other distinguishing features in the footage. Google Maps’ satellite imagery makes it possible to check if landmarks seen in a video tally with those at the purported location.
3: Many Syrian citizen journalists have set up Local Coordination Committees. These have been particularly active on Facebook. The LCCs cover different areas and cities and provide updates on battles and ground conditions in their particular region, making them invaluable for checking if an incident shown in a video was actually recorded to have happened there. LCCs also cherry-pick videos of particular events in their area, posting them online.
4: To find out what is being said about the video, take the unique identity code in the url of the video and search for it on Twitter. Often there is a burst in online exposure by people in Syria, when a video is new and hasn’t been seen before. The first person who shared it on Twitter may also well be the original owner of the video.
5: Finally, but most importantly, it’s always worth making direct contact with the uploader asking them about their content.
About the Author:
Photo: CUNY Journalism Press