News & Analysis 1-FpQJPvtKKcjt4_MrDcjweg

Published on September 15th, 2015 | by EJC

0

How A Production Company Faked ‘Instagram Migrant’ Account

This article was written by  Eliza Mackintosh and originally published by Storyful on 3 August, 2015. Republished with permission.

An Instagram account purportedly documenting a migrant’s journey from Dakar, Senegal, to Spain began trending on Sunday after the Huffington Post shared a story about it.

1-0KCJEpL15VotUMrOhyNM7A (1)

The Huffington Post’s story on the Instagram account, which treats it as legitimate. The Huffington Post UK contacted Abdou, who said he was in the town of Tarifa in Spain.

The story, “Migrant Instagrams His Perilous Journey By Truck And Rowing Boat To Reach Spain From North Africa,” gives a synopsis of the photos, posted by an Abdou Diouf, showing a smiling man as he appeared to make his way from his home in Senegal to Nouadhibou, a city in neighboring Mauritania, and then to Morocco and across the Mediterranean to Spain.

1-FpQJPvtKKcjt4_MrDcjweg

First photo shared by Abdou Diouf on July 21, which is described as showing him with family in Dakar before his journey.

The Huffington Post was not alone in treating Diouf’s story as legitimate. After the article was posted Sunday evening, the account was hit by a barrage of activity and followers. A number of Instagram users began commenting on Diouf’s photos, sharing messages that were both congratulatory and xenophobic.

At the time that Storyful found the Instagram account, we investigated it as we would any emerging social story. We reached out to the uploader, who responded by email, saying, “Im in tarifa at the moment with reduced conextion. My phone doesnt work here only wifi internet. What you want to know about my journey? Bless.”

1-guwY3_NOJQy8A3Ricgj79A

A photo shared by Abdou Diouf showing him having arrived safely on land in Spain.

The person described as Abdou Diouf of Dakar did not appear to have any social media presence outside of his Instagram account, which began sharing photos on July 21. Storyful searched the email address that was used in his correspondence — it turned up nothing in reverse searches.

Spanish production company Manson shared this video on July 22 showing a selection of scenes featured on Diouf’s account. The footage corresponds with the images from his journey. The video, which was posted on Vimeo, credits various people for the directing, casting, and production. It was also featured on a Facebook page for GETXOPHOTO, a festival dedicated to photography, which “supports the exploration of formats, stands and unconventional exhibition spaces to show […] different images.”

A photograph from the production company’s Instagram shows a poster featuring its name; it also appears in one of Diouf’s photographs.

1-A54CPIg5PnvoEwy2GjdbgQ

Production company Manson shared this image of a poster on July 15.

1-tQdu4FFELrJFcSk36G8hGA

The poster that is featured on Manson’s Instagram account appears in the background of this photo — the second shared by Abdou Diouf and described as ‘getting ready for new experiences.’

Through further investigation of the Instagram account, Storyful unearthed the profile of a handball player named Hagi Toure, who appears to be the same man pictured in the Abdou Diouf account. According to his Facebook profile, Toure lives in Pineda, in Catalonia, Spain.

1-CAiV8UqQsL4ia3eZJZj9Gw

Photo shared by Instagram account hagi19888 on July 30.

 

Storyful asked both Manson and GETXOPHOTO about Diouf’s story. Both parties confirmed with a press release that Diouf’s story was a project for the GETXOPHOTO exhibition aimed at reflecting “the way we process and share images of displacement and migration, in established media and on social networks.” See full press release below:

The creative agency and production company Volga presents this years press campaign for the GETXOPHOTO photography exhibition.

Directed by the Barcelona studio Manson, this years campaign in formed of a 60 second video and linked Instagram account that acts as a reflection on the way we process and share images of displacement and migration, in established media and on social networks

The piece is also a comment on how the use and importance of photography has changed radically in the last few years, with the image of travel inexorably linked to it’s ‘reality’. In this way photography is key to the social construct of ‘travel’ in a globalized society.

If this is true for industrial tourism — the endless search and sharing of 21st century takes on pastoral ideals — it applies equally to the increasing numbers of those who’s journeys are the result of necessity. Migrants and refugees, displaced by dictatorial regimes, the horrors of war and environmental and economic disasters.

About Getxophoto 2015

The festival, now in it’s eighth edition has chosen this years participants for the quality and integrity of their work. Examples include Paul Fusco, a Magnum photographer who will show ‘Funeral Train’, a work which takes as its focus the train that transported the corpse of President Kennedy from New York to Washington. Also showing work will be Spanish photographers including Reinaldo Louerio, who working from images from the archive of the national police force posits a reflection on the role of immigrants in Spanish society. All of this years participants are linked by the aesthetic, political and ethical content of their work.

The main takeaway for journalists is clear — it’s critical to treat all social content with a heavy dose of skepticism. When we are all searching and scanning for that one person who presents a narrative perfectly, particularly around current topics like migration into Europe, there is a readiness to believe that a story is true.

Tomás Peña, the director of the project, said in an email to Storyful that they knew people could believe Diouf’s story.

“We wanted to make people think,” Peña said.

Joana Sendra of GETXOPHOTO said in an email to Storyful that the goal of the project was to play with Western attitudes.

“It was a way of denouncing Western frivolity, in which we have to take selfies at all times and it seems that an event has not been experienced if you have not shared it,” Sendra wrote.

Some 137,000 migrants arrived in Greece, Italy, Malta and Spain between January and June of this year, according to data collected by the UN refugee agency. Nearly 2,000 more died in the attempt to reach Europe. By harnessing the language of Instagram — selfies and hashtags — Manson tapped into a collective desire to see the migrant’s perspective, to see the individual behind the statistics.

But the fact remains that very few of those 137,000-plus people have been able to share their experiences in this way. The challenge for journalists, then, is to find a way to tell those stories humanely, genuinely and accurately.

For more information on Storyful, visit Storyful.com and follow us at @Storyful

About the Author:

63582db4080fc745035e933e064d6e4a
 Eliza Mackintosh is a Brooklyn-based journalist working for Storyful – a social news agency that discovers, verifies, acquires and distributes timely video and user-generated content. Previously, she reported for the Washington Post as a special correspondent in London. While in the United Kingdom she  reported on culture, food trends, austerity measures, the London 2012 Olympics, rising rent prices, and, of course, the discovery of King Richard III’s skeleton in a parking lot. Follow on Twitter: @elizamackintosh

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


About the Author



Comments are closed.

Back to Top ↑